Is Tap Water Safe to Drink in Martha's Vineyard?

DetoxWater Editorial Team•Published November 5, 2026

Yes, EPA records show no health-based violations in the last 3 years for the Oak Bluffs Water District, Edgartown Water Department or Tisbury Water Works.

What does the EPA verdict mean?

The verdict reflects the records for these three public water systems, not a guarantee about every tap in Martha's Vineyard. Tisbury Water Works had other violations, including monitoring and reporting violations; those do not by themselves prove the water was contaminated.

For a broader comparison, see tap water safety by state. For a particular address, check the supplier and any current notices before relying on a past record.

Who supplies the water, and where does it come from?

The Oak Bluffs Water District is the main system listed for visitors. Edgartown Water Department and Tisbury Water Works also serve parts of Martha's Vineyard. All three are locally government-owned systems whose primary source is groundwater.

A hotel, rental or home may be served by a different system or a private well. Ask the property owner or manager which source supplies your tap; these three utility records do not establish the quality of a private well.

What does the EPA violation record show?

The following snapshot covers the last 3 years in EPA's records, retrieved November 3, 2026. Population figures are the numbers of people each system serves.

SystemPeople servedHealth-based violationsOpen violationsLead action-level exceedances reported
Oak Bluffs Water District24,000NoNone listedNone reported
Edgartown Water Department8,027NoNone listedNone reported
Tisbury Water Works6,082NoEnterococci and Consumer Confidence RuleNone reported

Tisbury Water Works had violations recorded in all 12 of the last 12 quarters. The record identifies monitoring and reporting and other violations involving enterococci, a group of bacteria, and the Consumer Confidence Rule, which concerns public water quality reporting. Monitoring and reporting violations mean missed or late tests or paperwork; they are not proof that bacteria were found in the water.

The record does not establish the details behind each violation. Ask Tisbury Water Works for its current notices and annual water quality report for more information.

What did PFAS testing find?

PFAS are a group of long-lasting chemicals often called “forever chemicals.” EPA's UCMR 5 was a one-time national monitoring survey conducted from 2023 to 2025; it is a snapshot, not continuous monitoring.

EPA has set drinking water limits of 4.0 parts per trillion (ppt) each for PFOA and PFOS. Neither was detected in the samples reported for these three systems:

SystemSampling periodPFOA detectedPFOS detected
Oak Bluffs Water DistrictJune 21–December 13, 20230 of 10 samples0 of 10 samples
Edgartown Water DepartmentJanuary 9–September 10, 20240 of 10 samples0 of 10 samples
Tisbury Water WorksMarch 12–September 18, 20240 of 6 samples0 of 6 samples

The reporting limit for both chemicals was 4.0 ppt. “Not detected” means a result was below that reporting limit, not necessarily that the concentration was zero. Regulatory compliance is based on running annual averages, so a comparison with these survey results alone does not determine compliance.

Oak Bluffs Water District also had detections in 4 of 230 results for other PFAS, with a maximum of 4.0 ppt. Edgartown Water Department and Tisbury Water Works reported no detections in their respective other-PFAS results. The PFOA and PFOS limits should not be applied to an unidentified other PFAS.

Could household plumbing add lead?

Yes. The EPA utility record does not test every home's pipes, fixtures or taps. No lead action-level exceedances were reported for the three systems in the last 3 years, but that does not rule out lead at an individual property.

EPA's lead action level is 15 parts per billion (ppb), while its health goal is zero. An action level is not a guarantee that a particular home's water is lead-free. If you are concerned, arrange a tap-water test through a certified laboratory and ask the utility about the service line.

Can you use the water for ice, brushing teeth and washing produce?

The utility records do not show a health-based violation for the three systems, but they cannot confirm conditions at an individual tap. Check current utility notices and ask your host which water source serves the property.

If an advisory applies, follow its instructions for drinking, making ice, brushing teeth and washing produce. Do not assume that a household filter or boiling will make water usable when a notice says not to use it.

How can you get extra protection?

Ask the utility for its latest annual water quality report and notices, and consider testing your tap if plumbing or a private well is a concern. Choose an independently certified filter that specifically claims to reduce the contaminant you are concerned about, such as lead or PFAS, and replace cartridges as directed. Boiling does not remove lead or PFAS.

Pregnant people, families preparing infant formula, and people with weakened immune systems should be especially careful about possible contamination and follow current local advice. If you suspect exposure or become ill after drinking water, contact a healthcare professional; seek prompt care for severe symptoms.

Where can you check the source data?

The violation information comes from EPA's Safe Drinking Water Act records, retrieved November 3, 2026: Oak Bluffs Water District EPA report, Edgartown Water Department EPA report, and Tisbury Water Works EPA report.

The PFAS results come from EPA UCMR 5 occurrence data, using the file dated October 15, 2026. For the most current local details, consult the relevant utility's notices and annual water quality report.

Frequently asked questions

Does clear tap water mean it is free of contaminants?

No. Some contaminants cannot be seen, tasted or smelled. A water test can answer questions about specific contaminants.

Do the EPA utility records cover a private well?

No. The records described here concern the three public water systems, not individual private wells. Ask the property owner about the well's testing history.

Do the population figures represent only year-round residents?

The figures are the numbers of people the systems serve; they should not be read as counts of year-round residents.