Tuna vs Sardines: Key Differences and Which to Choose

DetoxWater Editorial Team•Published November 5, 2026

Sardines generally contain less mercury than tuna, making them the better choice for frequent meals. Tuna is often leaner and milder, while sardines typically provide more omega-3 fats than canned tuna and more calcium when eaten with their bones.

Both can fit into a balanced diet. As with other healthy food comparisons, the best choice depends on the specific product, your preferences and how often you eat it.

What is the biggest difference between tuna and sardines?

The most consequential difference is mercury. Sardines are small fish with relatively low mercury levels. Tuna generally have more mercury because many species are larger predatory fish that accumulate it over their lives.

Not all tuna is the same. Canned light tuna, which commonly includes skipjack, generally has less mercury than albacore tuna. Bigeye tuna is a higher-mercury choice. The species matters whether tuna is sold canned or fresh, so check the label when it is available.

Lower mercury does not mean sardines are automatically better for every meal. Tuna can be a useful source of lean protein, particularly if you prefer its texture or taste. But if you eat fish often, mercury exposure is an important reason to include lower-mercury options such as sardines.

How do tuna and sardines compare?

The table compares the fish themselves and common canned products. Nutrient amounts vary by species, preparation, packing liquid and brand, so use the product label for a specific comparison.

AttributeTunaSardines
MercuryGenerally higher; varies substantially by speciesGenerally lower
ProteinHigh in protein; often lean, especially when packed in waterHigh in protein, with more fat than many canned tuna products
Omega-3 fatsProvides omega-3 fats; amounts vary by species and productGenerally provides more omega-3 fats than canned tuna
CalciumUsually less calcium in boneless productsCan provide more calcium when the soft bones are eaten
Vitamin DProvides vitamin D, with amounts varying by productProvides vitamin D, with amounts varying by product
SodiumCanned products vary; check the labelCanned products vary; check the label
Flavor and textureOften mild and firm or flakyUsually richer and stronger, with a softer texture
Common formsFresh, frozen, canned or in pouchesCommonly canned whole or as fillets; also sold fresh or frozen
Environmental impactDepends on the species, fishery and fishing methodAlso depends on the fishery and fishing method

For either fish, the packing liquid and seasonings affect the final product. Oil-packed fish can add calories if you eat the oil, while sauces and added salt can change the sodium content. Compare labels using the same serving size if those differences matter to you.

When should you choose tuna or sardines?

Choose tuna for a milder, often leaner protein

Tuna is useful when you want a firm, flaky fish that works in sandwiches, salads or pasta. Water-packed canned tuna is often a convenient lean-protein option, though the exact nutrition depends on the product.

If you eat tuna regularly, look at the species as well as the nutrition label. Choosing canned light tuna rather than albacore can reduce mercury exposure without requiring you to give up tuna altogether. A label that identifies the species gives you more useful information than one that simply says “tuna.”

Tuna’s mildness can also make it easier to pair with ingredients that add flavor or texture. Try it with vegetables, beans or whole grains for a meal that includes fiber as well as protein.

Choose sardines for lower mercury and edible bones

Sardines are a practical choice if you want fish more often while keeping mercury exposure lower. They also supply omega-3 fats, and canned sardines with their soft bones offer calcium that boneless fish generally does not provide in the same amount.

The bones in canned sardines are usually soft enough to eat. Boneless sardines are an option if you dislike the texture, but check the label: removing the bones can reduce the calcium you get. Sardines have a more pronounced flavor than tuna, so you may prefer them mashed into a salad or served with ingredients that balance their richness.

As with tuna, compare sodium and ingredients across cans. Sardines packed in a sauce may taste quite different from plain sardines, and their nutrition label will reflect what has been added.

Who should be careful?

People who are pregnant or breastfeeding, and parents choosing fish for children, should pay particular attention to mercury and species-specific fish advice. A health professional can help interpret that advice for your circumstances. People managing high blood pressure or kidney disease may also need to check sodium and discuss suitable choices with their care team.

If you have a fish allergy, avoid tuna and sardines unless your allergy specialist advises otherwise. Seek emergency help for symptoms of a severe allergic reaction, such as trouble breathing or throat swelling.

Can you combine tuna and sardines?

Yes. You can use tuna and sardines together in a salad, sandwich filling or pasta dish. Tuna can make the flavor milder, while sardines add richness; eating sardines with their bones can also add calcium.

Combining them does not cancel out the mercury in tuna. Your exposure depends on the types and amounts of fish you eat over time. Replacing some tuna with lower-mercury sardines can lower the mercury in the fish portion compared with using the same amount of tuna alone, but the tuna still contributes to your exposure.

For canned products, follow the package directions and refrigerate leftovers promptly in a covered container. Do not use a can that is bulging or leaking, and check the label for storage instructions once it is opened.

Choose tuna if you want a mild, often lean protein; choose sardines if you want a lower-mercury fish with omega-3 fats and calcium from edible bones.

Frequently asked questions

Does oil-packed fish contain more calories than water-packed fish?

It can, particularly if you eat the packing oil. Compare product labels using the same serving size to see the difference.

Are canned tuna and sardines ready to eat?

Commercially canned tuna and sardines are generally cooked and ready to eat. Check the package directions for the particular product.

Are tuna and sardines complete proteins?

Yes. Both provide all the essential amino acids your body needs from food.