Tuna vs Mackerel: Key Differences and Which to Choose
Mackerel is generally oilier and richer in omega-3 fats, while tuna is generally leaner, although both vary by species and preparation.
What is the decisive difference between tuna and mackerel?
The main difference is the fish’s natural fat content. Atlantic mackerel is an oily fish with a rich flavor, while tuna—especially canned light tuna packed in water—is often leaner and milder.
That difference affects both nutrition and cooking. Mackerel generally supplies more marine omega-3 fats, while tuna is often easier to use when you want a less pronounced fish flavor. Both provide protein, and both can fit into a varied diet.
Neither description applies to every product. Tuna species and cuts vary, and the liquid in a can affects what you eat. As with other healthy food comparisons, the most useful choice depends on the specific product and your priorities.
How do tuna and mackerel compare?
| Attribute | Tuna | Mackerel |
|---|---|---|
| Fat | Generally leaner, particularly canned light tuna in water | Generally oilier, especially Atlantic mackerel |
| Omega-3 fats | Contains omega-3 fats; amount varies by species and product | Generally richer in omega-3 fats, though amount varies |
| Protein | A source of protein | A source of protein |
| Flavor | Often mild to moderately pronounced | Usually richer and more distinctly fishy |
| Texture | Often firm and flaky | Often tender and flaky, with a moist, oily texture |
| Mercury | Canned light tuna is a lower-mercury choice; albacore is generally higher and bigeye is high | Atlantic mackerel is a lower-mercury choice; king mackerel is high |
| Common forms | Fresh, frozen or canned | Fresh, frozen, canned or smoked |
| Best uses | Sandwiches, salads, bowls and seared dishes | Salads, toast, grilled dishes and strongly flavored meals |
The table describes common products, not every species or preparation. For example, a fatty cut of tuna differs from canned light tuna, and mackerel packed in oil differs from a plain fillet.
Packing liquid and added salt matter when comparing cans. Check the label for the species, serving information and sodium, as well as whether the fish is packed in water, oil or a sauce. Comparing the same serving size makes the labels more useful.
Nutritional differences alone do not establish that one fish will produce a particular health outcome. The practical question is which species and preparation suit your meal and eating habits.
When should you choose tuna or mackerel?
Choose tuna for a milder, usually leaner option
Tuna can be a good choice when you want fish that blends into a dish rather than dominating it. Canned light tuna works well in sandwiches, bean salads and grain bowls, while a fresh tuna steak offers a firm texture for cooking.
For a leaner canned option, look for tuna packed in water. Oil-packed tuna can have a richer texture, but the added oil means it is not the same comparison as plain tuna. If you eat tuna regularly, identify the species rather than assuming all cans have the same mercury profile.
Choose mackerel for richness and omega-3 fats
Mackerel is useful when you want a fuller flavor or an oily fish that stays moist in a meal. Atlantic mackerel can be served with sharp or acidic ingredients, such as lemon, which balance its richness without requiring a complicated preparation.
Canned mackerel can be convenient for toast, salads or a quick bowl. Smoked mackerel has a stronger flavor and may contain more salt, so check the label if sodium matters to you. If the package does not identify the species, ask the seller or choose a clearly labeled product.
Consider mercury, allergies and food safety
Mercury differs substantially by species, so “tuna” and “mackerel” are not enough information on their own. The FDA lists canned light tuna, including skipjack, and Atlantic mackerel among its lower-mercury “Best Choices.” Albacore tuna is a “Good Choice,” while bigeye tuna and king mackerel are choices to avoid for people who are pregnant or may become pregnant, people who are breastfeeding, and children.
If you have a fish allergy, do not assume either fish is safe because you tolerate a different food; ask an allergist for individual advice. People who are pregnant should avoid raw or undercooked fish. Anyone with a condition requiring limits on sodium or a restricted diet can ask a clinician or dietitian which products fit their needs.
Can you combine tuna and mackerel?
Yes. Tuna and mackerel can be combined in a salad, fish spread or grain bowl. The milder tuna can soften the more pronounced flavor of mackerel, while mackerel adds richness.
Choose clearly labeled species and consider the mercury profile of both. Mixing a high-mercury fish with a lower-mercury fish does not remove the mercury already present. If you are choosing for someone who is pregnant, breastfeeding or a child, use the lower-mercury options discussed above.
For a simple meal, drain canned fish as desired, flake it with a fork and mix it with vegetables and a dressing you like. Draining changes the liquid and texture; it is not a reliable way to remove mercury from the fish.
Keep fresh fish refrigerated, separate raw fish from ready-to-eat foods, and cook it thoroughly. After opening canned fish, refrigerate it promptly in a covered container and follow the product’s storage guidance.
Choose tuna if you want a milder, usually leaner fish / choose mackerel if you want richer flavor and generally more omega-3 fats.
Frequently asked questions
Are tuna and mackerel the same fish?
No. Tuna and mackerel are different groups of fish, though common tuna and mackerel belong to the same fish family.
What does white tuna mean on a can?
White tuna refers to albacore tuna. Canned light tuna may include skipjack and other tuna species.
Does canned mackerel contain bones?
Some canned mackerel contains softened, edible bones, while other products are boneless. Check the label to see what the product contains.