Sardines vs Mackerel: Differences and Which to Choose
Sardines are generally a low-mercury choice, while mackerel’s mercury level varies substantially by species.
What is the biggest difference between sardines and mackerel?
The most important distinction is that the name mackerel covers fish with very different mercury levels. Atlantic mackerel and Pacific chub mackerel are low-mercury choices, but king mackerel is high in mercury. Sardines are generally low in mercury.
Both fish can provide protein and omega-3 fats, so the better choice depends on the species, how it is prepared and what you value in a meal. This comparison is part of our guide to healthy food comparisons.
There are no studies in the evidence provided that directly compare the health effects of eating sardines with those of eating mackerel. Nutrient amounts also vary by species, serving size and product, so neither fish is automatically superior in every respect.
How do sardines and mackerel compare?
| Attribute | Sardines | Mackerel |
|---|---|---|
| Mercury | Generally low in mercury. | Depends on species: Atlantic mackerel and Pacific chub mackerel are low; king mackerel is high. |
| Omega-3 fats | Provide marine omega-3 fats, including EPA and DHA; the amount varies. | Also provide EPA and DHA; the amount varies by species and preparation. |
| Protein | A source of protein, though the amount per serving varies by product. | Also a source of protein; compare labels using similar serving sizes. |
| Calcium | Canned sardines with edible bones can provide calcium. Boneless products may provide less. | Canned mackerel with edible bones can provide calcium; boneless fillets may provide less. |
| Vitamin D and B12 | Can provide both vitamins, with amounts varying by product. | Can also provide both vitamins, with amounts varying by species and product. |
| Taste | Often distinctly fishy and savory, although sauces and preparations change the flavor. | Flavor varies by species; some products have a rich, pronounced taste. |
| Texture | Small canned fish are often tender and may be sold whole or as fillets. | Often sold as larger pieces or fillets; texture varies from tender to firm. |
| Bones | Canned bones are usually softened and edible, but boneless options are available. | Canned bones may be softened and edible; fillets can also be sold boneless. |
| Sodium | Varies with added salt, brine and sauces. | Varies with added salt, brine, smoking and sauces. |
| Packing liquid | Available in water, oil and sauces; the liquid affects the product’s nutrition and taste. | Also available in water, oil and sauces; check the label for the product you buy. |
| Availability | Commonly sold canned; fresh or frozen options depend on location. | Sold canned, fresh, frozen and smoked, depending on location and species. |
| Environmental impact | Depends on the stock and fishing method, not just the fish’s name. | Also depends on the stock and fishing method, which differ among species. |
For a useful nutrition comparison, check the labels on the actual products and compare similar serving sizes. Pay attention to whether the listed serving includes packing liquid or refers to drained fish, as well as whether bones are included. An oil-packed product may differ substantially from a water-packed one, even when the fish is otherwise similar.
If you are comparing fresh fish rather than cans, ask the seller for the mackerel species. A generic label does not give you enough information to judge its mercury level.
When should you choose sardines or mackerel?
Choose sardines for a simple low-mercury option
Sardines are a convenient choice when you want a fish that is generally low in mercury without having to distinguish among several mackerel species. Canned sardines are also useful if you want a shelf-stable food that can go straight into a meal.
For calcium, look for canned sardines with bones and check the nutrition label. If the taste or appearance of whole sardines puts you off, boneless fillets may be easier to enjoy, though their calcium content can differ.
Sardines work well on toast, in pasta or alongside a salad. Plain versions let you control the seasoning; flavored versions can make preparation quicker, but check the label if you are watching sodium.
Choose mackerel when you know the species
Mackerel can be a good choice when you prefer its flavor or want larger pieces of fish. Atlantic mackerel and Pacific chub mackerel offer low-mercury options; look for the species name on the package or ask the seller.
Check whether the mackerel is fresh, canned or smoked before choosing a preparation. Smoked or sauced products can have a different flavor and sodium content from plain fish, while oil-packed and water-packed cans can differ in their nutrition.
If a can or menu says only “mackerel,” ask for clarification rather than assuming it is a low-mercury species. When the species cannot be identified, sardines are the more straightforward choice for someone trying to limit mercury exposure.
Who should be careful?
People who are pregnant or may become pregnant, breastfeeding people and children should be especially careful about mercury and avoid king mackerel. A clinician can help with individual seafood choices, particularly if a child has a restricted diet or you are uncertain about local fish advisories.
Anyone with a fish allergy should avoid fish unless their clinician advises otherwise. If you need to limit sodium because of a medical condition, compare labels and ask your clinician or dietitian which products fit your diet.
Can you combine sardines and mackerel?
Yes. Sardines and mackerel can be eaten in the same meal or alternated across meals. Combining them does not cancel out mercury, so identify the mackerel species first and choose a low-mercury option if that is your priority.
For an easy meal, add drained sardines and mackerel to a salad or serve them on toast with lemon and herbs. Taste before adding salt, particularly if either fish is canned in brine, smoked or packed in a seasoned sauce. You can also keep the portions separate so each person can choose the flavor and texture they prefer.
For canned fish, do not use a damaged, leaking or bulging can. Refrigerate leftovers promptly and follow the package’s storage directions. If using locally caught fish, check the applicable local fish advisory rather than relying only on the species name.
Choose sardines if you want a straightforward low-mercury option with potentially calcium-rich edible bones; choose mackerel if you prefer its flavor or texture and can verify the species.
Frequently asked questions
Are canned sardines and mackerel already cooked?
Shelf-stable canned sardines and mackerel are generally cooked during processing and can be eaten without further cooking. Check the package instructions for the product you buy.
Do you need to rinse canned sardines or mackerel?
Rinsing is not necessary. You can drain the packing liquid or rinse the fish for taste, but use the label rather than assuming how much sodium remains.
Are sardines and mackerel the same kind of fish?
No. Sardines and mackerel are different groups of fish, and each name can refer to more than one species. Identifying the species is especially important for mackerel because mercury levels vary.